News

Miami, FL — U.S. Senator Marco Rubio (R-FL) sent a letter to Google CEO Sundar Pichai and Apple CEO Tim Cook calling them out for bowing to censorship requests from Putin’s regime. Specifically, Rubio highlighted that both tech companies acceded to Moscow’s demand that they take down an app designed to coordinate protest voting in the Russian parliamentary elections from September 17-19, 2021. The app was created by imprisoned opposition leader Alexei Navalny.
 
In April, following the passage of Georgia’s election integrity law, both companies spoke out regarding voter access. At the time, Cook noted, “Apple believes that, thanks in part to the power of technology, it ought to be easier than ever for every eligible citizen to exercise their right to vote.” 
 
“By bowing to Moscow’s demand, Google and Apple have made themselves complicit in the censorship of an oppressive, authoritarian regime,” Rubio wrote. “You have set a disturbing precedent for both of your companies, and their peers, one with ramifications for billions of users of your technologies worldwide. Why your companies would choose to assist a regime that, just days beforehand, began fining Facebook and Twitter for refusing to remove content per its beck and call, as well as reportedly blocked users’ access to Smart Voting material hosted on Google Docs, is beyond comprehension.”
 
The full text of the letter is below. 
 
Dear Mr. Pichai and Mr. Cook:
 
I write to express serious concern with the recent decisions by Google and Apple to accede to illegitimate and outrageous censorship requests by the Russian government. This month, both of your companies removed from your respective app stores an app designed to coordinate protest voting in the September 17-19, 2021 Russian parliamentary election, which was supported by allies of opposition leader Alexei Navalny. The decision to remove the app was widely reported to have followed threats from Moscow to arrest employees of both of your companies.
 
The “Smart Voting” app in question was designed by a Navalny-led campaign to consolidate protest votes and recommend the political candidates that were best positioned to defeat United Russia, the dominant, pro-Putin party in the State Duma. Your companies removed the app from the Google Play Store and App Store at a critical moment, just as millions of Russians were going to the polls to vote. By intervening as you did, your companies denied a legitimate political opposition the opportunity to organize and get out the vote – and potentially even its rightful seats in the Russian Duma – and enabled Vladimir Putin’s continued suppression of Russians’ fundamental right to elect their leaders.
 
By bowing to Moscow’s demand, Google and Apple have made themselves complicit in the censorship of an oppressive, authoritarian regime. You have set a disturbing precedent for both of your companies, and their peers, one with ramifications for billions of users of your technologies worldwide. Why your companies would choose to assist a regime that, just days beforehand, began fining Facebook and Twitter for refusing to remove content per its beck and call, as well as reportedly blocked users’ access to Smart Voting material hosted on Google Docs, is beyond comprehension.
 
In the same vein, I am also concerned by YouTube’s decision to block RadioFreeEurope and RadioLiberty from airing a clip from an August 30, 2021 Russian election debate broadcast on state television. In the clip, journalist and candidate Maksim Shevchenko called for the release of Alexei Navalny, and other political prisoners. According to RadioFreeEurope, the state-owned All-Russia State Television and Radio Company requested that YouTube block use of the video on the basis of copyright infringement. As Shevchenko noted, however, the Russian government lacks the right to claim such infringement on so central “a part of the political process.”
 
In response to your companies’ decision to remove the app, Navalny wrote from prison that “[i]f something surprised me in the latest elections, it was not how Putin forged the results, but how obediently the almighty Big Tech turned into his accomplices… I know that most of those who work at Google, Apple, etc. are honest and good people. I urge them not to put up with the cowardice of their bosses.”
 
When presented with an opportunity to support your own goals of transparency, openness, advancement of human rights, and internet freedom, you instead bowed to the demands of an authoritarian regime.  I strongly urge you to reconsider your decision to do so and request greater background and transparency from both Google and Apple about the decision-making process that led to these censorious actions on behalf of Putin’s Russia.
 
Thank you for your attention to this matter. I look forward to your prompt response. 
 
Sincerely,